Hello all,

Need some sage advice. I had an E36 Convertible, and made the mistake of trading it in on a Lexus. Now I'm coming back to BMW...

I'm looking at a 2009 328 convertible with 26K miles, one owner, local car, Very vanilla...
or a 2008 335 convertible with 31K miles. Navigation, two owners, first owner lived in buffalo, was purchased at an auction, but otherwise clean and seems to have a good maintenance records. Checked the carfax and called the dealer.

I plan on buying an extended warranty for 5 years 100K miles.

What would you recommend. I like the thought of the 335 and the navigation, but is it going to be more expensive to maintain and operate. Any know issues on either car that I should know?

Thanks in advance!