I had recently recommended him and the person was very glad I did. He found a problem that various dealers couldn't.

Spoken like a true used car salesman. :rolleyes:
I'm willing to bet they are doing as poorly as the 'various' BMW dealers.

And don't expect a shop to warranty the labor if a part fails.

Feel free to express your opinion about your experience.
Everyone has had good and bad experiences from the same independent or dealer.

I want to say the Tidewater area of VA but I'm not sure.

Yea, Bill is no longer at J&F. And thanks for the list!

http://www.dvsmith.net/bmw/service/dc_service_shops.php