(2009) Tire Thread

[Biggins]

It’s time to spark a debate on everyone’s favorite topic. Since no one has mentioned anything about tires yet this year, I’ll start. This is a list of all the relevant tires that I believe should be competitive in each class. I might have missed one or two, but I think I got most of them.

Showroom tires 210+ rating (for NCC S# class):
Whatever is on your car, maybe these-
Continental ContiSportContact 2
Goodyear Eagle F1 GS-D3
Michelin Pilot Sport PS2

“Street” tires 140+ rating (for NCC T# class):
Bridgestone RE-01R
Bridgestone RE-11
Dunlop Direzza Sport Z1 Star Spec
Falken Azenis RT-615
Federal 595RS-R
Hankook RS-2
Hankook RS-3
Kumho MX
Kumho XS
Kumho SPT (wet)
Maxxis MA-Z1 Victra
Nitto NT05
Toyo R1R
Yokohama Advan Neova AD07
Yokohama Advan Neova AD08

DOT-R tires (for NCC M# class):
Avon Tech R-A
BFGoodrich g-Force R1
Hoosier A6
Hoosier Radial Wet
Hoosier R6
Kumho V700
Kumho V710
Kumho Victoracer
Michelin Pilot Sport Cup
Nitto NT01
Toyo R888
Yokohama Advan A048

[BradMW]

I think running an auto convertible should get me an extra 10 rating for free, just sayin'.

[Nick325xiT 5spd]

Reports I'm hearing are that the Kumho XS is the current tire to have for ST classes, although we will see what the Advan AD08s will do. I'm running the XS presently, and they have a very impressive feel. I'll know more in two weeks when I've run them at Fedex.

Of the showroom tires, the PS2 is a clear "winner," although the cost is so absurdly high and the resistance to cording at the edges so low that I would rather spend the extra money on classing up.

As for R-tires, Hoosier A6 or Kumho V710. The 710 will last a lot longer for almost the same performance.

[hoyabmw]

I dunno nick. The Toyo R1R looks to be an insane tire for ST. It's almost certainly the best tire to have for rain, no matter what class you're in. Look at Ian's times from the AI event Saturday--he was the only one on the R1R. I'm even considering them for SP rains over hoosier since I don't care about the contingency.
The RE-11 is also a killer ST tire.

National winners for R-comps will be running the A6 as it is significantly lighter than the 710, and definitely quicker, but it doesn't last as long.

One big thing is who makes a tire that's the right size.

[Nick325xiT 5spd]

Everything I hear about the R1R is that it's not good on heavy cars. Otherwise, I would have seriously considered it. Sadly, an '89 CRX Si doesn't help refute that.

Edit: That said, the R1R is, I suspect, a much better street tire. The Kumho XS has the road feel of some frankensteinian combination of an RA-1 and a Hoosier.

[woodym3]

The Kumho XS has the road feel of some frankensteinian combination of an RA-1 and a Hoosier.

RRT is putting the finishing touches on a Z3 M Coupe for this year's One Lap that will be running the Kumho XS - 265/40-18 front and 315/30-18 rear as I recall.
Those big tires will be needed to handle the 600+ hp turbo 2.8 engine.

[mcoupemindy]

RRT is putting the finishing touches on a Z3 M Coupe for this year's One Lap that will be running the Kumho XS - 265/40-18 front and 315/30-18 rear as I recall.
Those big tires will be needed to handle the 600+ hp turbo 2.8 engine.

Yeah, those XS's are mean!

I have to gawk at one of my co-workers cars every time he brings it to work. Cobra Rep (~500 hp) with 315's in the front and 335's in the rear.

[Sammyzuko]

RRT is putting the finishing touches on a Z3 M Coupe for this year's One Lap that will be running the Kumho XS - 265/40-18 front and 315/30-18 rear as I recall.
Those big tires will be needed to handle the 600+ hp turbo 2.8 engine.

Turbo 2.8 eh, interesting. I'll have to keep an eye on it during the One Lap of A.

[Reach]

Anyone hear much about the Nitto NT-05 yet? I've been reading some fantastic reviews of them online, but there is some kind of 'too good to be true' feeling about them, like they are planted reviews.

Would likely be going for a square set of 265's on my M3 later this summer, and I haven't figured out what to run for ax+street duty.

[woodym3]

Nitto Nt-05, Bridgestone RE-11, Kumho XS, Yokohama Neova AD-08, etc. . . . . .all of these new "Ultra Performance Street Tires" are so new to the market I don't think any one has the handle on which will be better for autocross, track, rain, longevity, etc. And will any of them top last year's darlings such as the Dunlop Direzza Z1 Star Spec or Bridgestone Re-01R. I believe the next issue of Grassroots Motorsports promises to have a comparison test.

[Biggins]

As Woody mentioned, it's likely we won't have a clear answer for you for another 2-3 months. Most of these tires just hit the street in March, so we're learning each week.

I think the Nitto NT05 could be a great option if it has similar characteristics to the NT01r-comp. However, from pure speculation, I think the Kumho, Bridgestone, Yokohama and Dunlops will be the favorites in 2009. I've heard the same things as Nick about the Toyos.

[Nick325xiT 5spd]

The RE01R was never well regarded (except as a nice compromise for comfort as well as price). It wasn't even close to the AD07.

[hoyabmw]

The RE01R was never well regarded (except as a nice compromise for comfort as well as price). It wasn't even close to the AD07.

Nick, that may have been true for the BMW crowd, but the RE01R was definitely a front runner in ST on Minis.

[Nick325xiT 5spd]

Nick, that may have been true for the BMW crowd, but the RE01R was definitely a front runner in ST on Minis.

The complaint with the RE01R was similar to the complaint with the R1R - it flops around and can't really handle the weight. I'm not that surprised.

It looks like Brian Hair may be driving my car this weekend too, so I will a) actually show up, and b) might have a competent driver to compare notes with. I look forward to getting some data.

[Zcruizer]

Ok Nick, you sound like you've been around a tire or two. Let me clarify my statement before. When I was shopping for tires, I wanted a good balance of performance and comfort as this is a pleasure car. My car is not a race car and I don't want it to be, buying tires that are barely listed as street tires made about as much sense as putting a fart cannon (catback or version of) on. What's more, I need to keep this car in Showroom class to even compete in autox. The Nitto NT05 has a treadwear too low for my needs, 200, according to the Nitto website. I need a 210 or higher. Speaking of the website, when I stated the Invo and NT05 were similar I was basing this off the chart that is given. Both of their wet and dry performance indicators are very close with the Invo scoring higher than the NT05 in the wet performance. You can look for yourself to see the comparison in the ride comfort and quietness categories. Then you'll understand why I tried the Invos instead.